Dear Kerry: “Sick of all the Whining”
My 12 year old son whines constantly and it drives me absolutely crazy. It’s almost like it’s his default way of speaking. I don’t want to constantly berate him – but I am not sure how to curb the whining?
Sick of All the Whining
For better or worse, this seems to be rather common for kids this age. I know that doesn’t make it any less aggravating for you to live with, but hopefully you at least know you are in good company with a lot of other parents.
If you focus on putting an end to the whining, you will end up putting your attention on what you DON’T want.
Focus instead on what you DO want; for example, calm voice, doing what you ask the first time, respectful words, pleasant tone. I call this “Parenting the Invisible” because it’s hard for us to notice when our kids do it. We tend to take the good, quiet, cooperative behavior for granted. Our brains are wired to hone in on the undesirable behaviors. If you pay attention, however, to the little, quiet, good behaviors and nice way of speaking, you’re likely to see that they actually do exist even when it seems like they don’t. If you can reward those in some way, you are helping your son grow the good behaviors. Rewards can be small and simple like a smile or nice word or affectionate touch and thanks. Even better, you can set up a plan for your son to earn something worth earning by having a point system and earning a point with every good behavior. Dr. Kazdin outlines a specific strategy for this in his book, The Everyday Parenting Toolkit.
I think the only way to really make “Parenting the Invisible” work is to set timers. When I’m really working it with my 12 year old son, I have to set a timer to go off every 20-30 minutes to remind me that I’m watching for the invisible. If I don’t set a timer, I forget. I like to give myself a certain chunk of an evening that I’m focused on being diligent about parenting this way and during which he can earn points. It’s not realistic to expect ourselves to do it perfectly all the time, especially if we have other kids and other distractions.
It’s easy to say, “I shouldn’t have to reward this; he should just do it because it’s the right way to act.”
Often times we parents have to give our kids external reasons to do the right things until they develop an internal compass that guides them.
This internal compass kicks in for different kids at different ages depending on their temperament and life stressors, among other things.
Another idea is to stay as calm as possible and simply make an enforceable statement: “I will help you when I hear you ask in a respectful way.” Then go quiet and do not argue or engage with his whining. If we parents respond and argue and engage when our kids are nasty to us, we teach them that this is an OK way to talk to people. It’s better for us to let them know that we will be available to provide services, help, time, etc, when they treat us respectfully. Think “FUTURE SPOUSE.” If you don’t want your son to grow up treating his spouse the way he’s treating you, then do not reward the nasty tone. Stay calm, go quiet, and be available when you are treated well.
One more idea for you is the Love & Logic® notion of putting an end to whining and arguing by going “Brain Dead” and using a “One-Liner.” Check out these videos to learn more:
Good luck and please let me know how it goes!
With love and laughter,
Kerry Stutzman, MSW, LMFT
©2015 Kerry Stutzman, Head & Heart Parents